Skip to main content

The Square Grouper Bar & Grill



Name: Donna Ferenci
Occupation: Retired
Lives In:Marathon, FL
Restaurant Pick: Square Grouper
Reviewed:Square Grouper

Very Fun! Classy location, the lower Keys that offers unique flavor combinations + FRESH food. Unbelievable taste sensations- terrific atmosphere- we had a great experience! Having both locations in the same building is brilliant! For dinner we had the portobello fries/ goat cheese/ poutine. Our entrée was crab cakes and special meatballs. For dessert we had bread pudding/ brownie with ice cream and for drinks, tap beer/wine. The taste of the food was very flavorful and the décor is modern- Keys eclectic- CLEAN. “My new joint” is upstairs- where we wait until our table was ready. We LOVED the casual ambiance, the solo guitar, the service was terrific! Also the “garden” outside offers fresh herbs + garnishes.

Name: Alan Newman 
Occupation: Sales Manager
Lives In: Miami/ Islamorada
Restaurant Pick:Hideaway Cafe
Reviewed: Square Grouper

As you pull up to a seemingly unassuming steel building on the side of US1 in Cudjoe Key, you wonder if you are at the right place. The Square Grouper is definitely a destination restaurant in every sense of the word. There is truly nothing else like it in the Keys. As you pass cow troughs that double as planters laden with fresh herbs you will realize that lunch time is the easiest to score a table in the dining room. Staff is always warm and friendly and service is always good. The menu is pretty extensive but make sure to check out the specials board to see what is local and fresh. The wine and cocktail program is solid so indulge in a glass or two. Once your order is in you start noticing some interesting details throughout. That ties back to the fact that a square grouper is not a marine creature… You will have to ask your server to extrapolate on that fact. Drinks come out in just the right amount of time and food is never far behind. Portions are ample enough to share and I recommend ordering across the board to get a little taste of everything. Pricing is fair given the quality of the meal. The only problem with dining here is the car ride back home…you will be so full you might fear falling asleep at the wheel. Dining at The Square Grouper is definitely a departure from the normal Keys restaurant experience. This is certainly not your typical fried seafood joint. From the moment you walk into the restaurant you know that you are somewhere special…from the food, to the décor, and ending with warm service.

Name: Lenuam Garcia 
Occupation: Real Estate Broker
Lives In: Homestead
Restaurant Pick: Gilbert’s Resort
Reviewed: Square Grouper

I arrived to the restaurant and saw at least a group of 5 people waiting. I hoped that I can get in quick, I was really hungry. I went inside looked around for some guidance on where to sit 10-15 before the host arrived. I did not want to wait therefore I chose the bar. The host was friendly and made space for me at the bar. My waitress/ bartender was very nice and energetic singing dancing real fun. I ordered a mojito and seared scallops with a bacon mushroom vinaigrette that was very tasty. I then ordered the Square Grouper Seafood Stew well recommended by the waitress. I really enjoyed the stew however I did have to order a side of mix rice to complete the dish and yes I had a great time. I was entertained the entire time just looking at the people having fun, talking to the people and listening to all the fishing stories. I really like the environment and I'm sure to go back to The Square Grouper Bar & Grill.

Restaurant Information

Location: 22658 Overseas Hwy, Cudjoe Key, FL 33042 
Parking: Yes
Phone: (305)745-8880
Restaurant Owners:
Executive Chef:
Pastry Chef:

Type of Cuisine: Fresh Local Seafood +Meats
Signature Dishes: House smoked fish dip, Grouper fish sandwich, conch chowder, seared scallops, flash fried conch, key lime pie
Vegetarian Options: Yes, lots
Alcohol Served: Full bar
Corkage Fee:
Bottle Limit:

Restaurant Hours: 
Monday –IN SEASON- 11:00 AM-2:30 PM/5:00 PM-10:00 PM 
Tuesday –11:00 AM-2:30 PM/5:00 PM-10:00 PM 
Wednesday – 11:00 AM-2:30 PM/5:00 PM-10:00 PM 
Thursday –11:00 AM-2:30 PM/5:00 PM-10:00 PM 
Friday – 11:00 AM-2:30 PM/5:00 PM-10:00 PM 
Saturday – 11:00 AM-2:30 PM/5:00 PM-10:00 PM 
Sunday –Closed

Meals Served: Local seafood
Prix Fix Menu: No
Take-Out: Yes
Delivery: N/A
Average Dinner Price Range (per person, full meal, tax, 20% gratuity, w/o alcohol): $25
Average Lunch Price Range (per person, full meal, tax, 20% gratuity, w/o alcohol): $15
Payment Options: do you accept credit cards and if so, which ones? All
Accept Reservations: No
Need Reservations: N/A
How far in advance do you require reservations be made: N/A

Accommodations for Children: Yes
Dining Style: Casual, eclectic
Disabled Access: Yes
Restaurant Size: Large
Accommodate Groups: Yes
Private Dining Room: YesNo
Tables with Scenic Views: Yes
Outdoor Dining: No
Entertainment: Yes